Brazilian president: “The developed world imports oil with no tariffs, yet they place an absurd tariff on Brazilian ethanol”

In Brazil, President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva called on industrial nations to “stop your hypocrisy”, and drop agricultural tariffs on Brazilian ethanol to save the Doha round of world trade talks. The Doha round, launched in 2001, has failed to produce an agreement because of disputes between developed and undeveloped countries over agricultural subsidies and tariffs.

Lula said it was “inconceivable” that developed nations have blamed biofuels for higher global food prices while tariffs are in place. “The world does not produce biofuels and has 800 million people who go to sleep hungry. Those who criticize biofuels have never criticized the price of oil. The developed world imports oil with no tariffs, yet they place an absurd tariff on Brazilian ethanol,” he said.

Last month, the president of the Brazilian Sugarcane Industry Association proposed that the US establish a variable ethanol tariff linked to the price of oil, if it would not abolish the ethanol tariff altogether. Proponents of the tariff repeal, who range from Sen. Charles Schumer (D-NY) and Sen. Richard Lugar (R-Ind) to Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, say that increased Brazilian imports will reduce the overall cost of fuel, relieve pressure on food prices, and reduce US dependence on foreign oil.

Opponents, led by Sen. Charles Grassley (R-IA) said that repealing the tariff would cause US taxpayers to subsidize Brazilian ethanol (as it would qualify for the 51-cent blenders credit), and said that Brazilian ethanol could be imported duty-free so long as it is partially processed in the Caribbean, under the Caribbean Basin initiative. An extension of the tariff to 2010 is contained in the Senate version of the Farm Bill, but the provision is opposed by the Bush Administration on the grounds that it adds a tax provision to a farm bill.

Analyst F.O. Licht projected that Brazilian ethanol exports will increase 15 percent in 2008 to 1.06 billion gallons. The company said that sugarcane production costs have decreased 4 percent while competing feedstock costs, such as corn or wheat, have risen more than 40 percent, creating favorable competitive conditions. The 16 percent rise in gasoline prices would prompt increased exports to Europe.

Petrobras has set an export target of 1.2 billion gallons for 2012, including both first- and second-generation ethanol. The company linked this export target to its plans for an ethanol pipeline connecting both Goias and Minas Gerais states with Sao Paulo state.

November 2007 ethanol exports from Brazil were down 40 percent from 2006, falling from 132 million gallons to 80 million. The fall in US demand, resulting from a production glut in the United States, caused the fall, and resulted in more than 63 percent of shipments to go to Europe.

Recently, the head of energy development for Petrobras blamed EU and US tariffs for a massive shortfall in planned ethanol exports, and said that the effort by Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva to lower the trade barriers has not produced results.

Free Subscription to the Daily Biofuels Digest e-newsletter

Related Stories

Iowa Senator leads effort to close loophole circumventing Brazilian ethanol tariff

In Washington, Sen. Chuck Grassley is leading an effort to close a loophole allowing oil companies to circumvent the tariff on Brazilian ethanol. The loophole allows oil companies to receive a rebate ...

Brazil’s Lula bemoans US ethanol tariff, Obama says “It’s not going to change overnight.”

In Washington, President Barack Obama said that his administration would work with Brazil on development of ethanol and acknowledged the tension between the two countries over the US ethanol tariff, b...

Brazilian President Lula asks for US investor support of ethanol tariff repeal

Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva appealed to a US-based investor group yesterday for help and support in eliminating the 53-cent-per-gallon import tariff on Brazilian ethanol. Silva has s...

US Energy Secretary says new US budget, due Monday, will “deal with” Brazilian ethanol tariff

In Washington, U.S. Energy Secretary Sam Bodman, commenting on the future of the ethanol tariff, said that the Bush Administration "will start to deal with that question" in the 2009 US Budget that th...

“Over my dead body” says Senator Ben Nelson to Bush proposal for ethanol tariff reform

In Washington, Midwestern lawmakers have vehemently opposed moves by the Bush administration to reduce or eliminate the tariff on Brazilian ethanol imports. Sen. Chuck Grassley, the ranking Republican...

Brazil on verge of WTO complaint against US over ethanol tariffs

Brazil is readying its challenge of US ethanol tariffs at the Wolrd Trade Organization. The 54-cent tariff is said by the Brazilians to be an illegal tariff under WTO rules. Unica has been working wit...